| 1 | Fr. Paul Limacher | (1851-1862) | 11 years |
| 2 | Fr. Bartholomaus Bartels | (1861-1863) | 2 years |
| 3 | Fr. Peter Peters | (1863-1874) | 11 years |
| 4 | Fr. Karl Oberprantacher | (1874-1876) | 2 years |
| 5 | Fr. Joseph Meckel | (1876-1896) | 20 years |
| 6 | Fr. August Schlegel | (1896-1903) | 7 years |
| 7 | Fr. Ferdinand Stick | (1903-1911) | 8 years |
| 8 | Fr. John Gramke | (1911-1919) | 8 years |
| 9 | Fr. Joseph DeChene | (1919-1927) | 8 years |
| 10 | Fr. August Hohl | (1927-1942) | 15 years |
| 11 | Msgr. William Whalen | (1943-1970) | 27 years |
| 12 | Msgr. Lawrence Wiskirchen | (1970-1981) | 11 years |
| 13 | Fr. Martin Mangan | (1981-1987) | 6 years |
| 14 | Fr. David Peters | (1987-2007) | 20 years |
| 15 | Fr. Charles Edwards | (2007-2015) |
8 years |
| 16 | Fr. Pat G. Jakel | (2015 to Present) | 8 Year |
